Illegal immigration, its impact and reform
Sep 28
7 min read
2
31
0
Key Takeaways
Drivers of Illegal Immigration
Economic hardship, violence, political instability, and limited legal avenues for migration are key drivers. Many individuals flee dangerous conditions in their home countries in pursuit of safety, better livelihoods, and opportunities for their families.
Illegal Immigrant Trends
Recent years have seen fluctuating patterns in illegal immigration, influenced by global crises, stricter border controls, and changing US policies. Migrant surges at the border are often linked to regional instability in Latin America, as well as shifting economic conditions in the U.S.
Solutions to Illegal Immigration
Effective solutions require comprehensive immigration reform, which could include expanding legal immigration pathways, addressing root causes in migrants’ home countries, and improving border security. Balancing enforcement with humanitarian support is crucial for creating sustainable, long-term solutions.
Immigration has long been a key component of America’s history and development. While "legal" immigration is a structured part of the US system, "illegal" immigration presents a series of economic, social, and logistical challenges. This guide explores the burden of "illegal" immigration in the US, including its effects on the country as a whole, individual states, and specific cities, backed by statistics and trends.
Definition Of Illegal Immigration In The US
"Illegal" immigration refers to the unauthorized entry or residence of individuals within the United States. According to recent estimates, about 11.5 million undocumented immigrants live in the US, making up about 3.5% of the total population. These numbers, though fluid, have significant impacts on public services, the economy, and law enforcement across the country.
People often choose to immigrate illegally to the United States due to a combination of push and pull factors. Many are driven by extreme poverty, violence, and political instability in their home countries, seeking safety and better economic opportunities for themselves and their families. Others are motivated by the lack of legal pathways to immigration, as the US immigration system can be complex, slow, and inaccessible for many. While the risks of illegal aliens are high, including dangerous border crossings and the threat of deportation, the promise of a more stable and prosperous life in the US remains a powerful incentive for those facing dire circumstances.
The Economic Burden of Undocumented Immigrants
National Impact
"Illegal" immigration places an economic burden on the US, particularly in sectors like education, healthcare, and law enforcement. Estimates vary, but a study by the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) in 2023 concluded that "illegal" immigration costs American taxpayers around $151 billion annually, with increased spending on healthcare, education, and other social services. This reflects a sharp increase from earlier estimates, suggesting that the burden is growing.
The federal government and individual states share the costs of handling "illegal" immigration. However, states with larger populations of undocumented immigrants bear a disproportionate share of these expenses.
Impact on Public Services
Education
Undocumented immigrants and their children contribute to the increasing costs of public education. According to FAIR, states spend an estimated $78 billion annually on K-12 education for undocumented immigrants and their children, including those who are U.S.-born.
Healthcare
Emergency medical services for undocumented immigrants present another significant cost. Federal law mandates that hospitals treat all patients in emergency rooms, regardless of immigration status, placing additional stress on an already burdened healthcare system. The FAIR report estimates that $23 billion is spent annually on healthcare for undocumented immigrants.
State and Local Costs
The fiscal burden of illegal immigration is particularly evident in border states such as California, Texas, and Arizona, which account for a substantial portion of the undocumented population. California alone incurs an estimated cost of $30.3 billion annually, the highest in the nation. States with smaller immigrant populations, like Alabama and Mississippi, also face financial strains, but on a smaller scale.
In some cities, the strain on resources is especially visible. For instance, Los Angeles County has seen significant increases in costs related to public education, healthcare, and housing services for undocumented immigrants. New York City faces similar challenges, with its extensive public health and education systems being overburdened by the sheer number of immigrants seeking assistance.
Social and Cultural Impacts
Overburdening of Local Services
In some cities and towns, the arrival of undocumented immigrants has led to stretched public services and infrastructure. Sanctuary cities, which limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, often face added pressure. For example, in Chicago, the public school system and healthcare infrastructure are reportedly strained due to the influx of undocumented immigrants.
Challenges in Law Enforcement
"Illegal" immigration has also placed a significant burden on law enforcement agencies across the country. States like Arizona and Texas, which share borders with Mexico, have seen increased costs related to border security and policing. The US spends approximately $25 billion annually on securing the southern border, including costs associated with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
Impact on States, Cities, and Towns
In states like Texas, where an estimated 1.6 million undocumented immigrants reside, the strain on local resources is immense. Texas spends around $13.1 billion annually on public services for illegal immigrants, with the education sector being the most heavily impacted.
In Florida, another state with a significant undocumented population, the annual cost is estimated at $8.1 billion. The state’s healthcare system, in particular, is struggling to meet the demand from undocumented residents.
On a city level, New York City has seen rising costs related to providing services for its immigrant population. In 2022, the city estimated that it spends over $10 billion annually on services for undocumented immigrants, including healthcare, education, and housing.
"Illegal" Immigration Manifests Itself In Xenophobia
"Illegal" immigration remains a hotly debated topic in US politics. Recent policy shifts have been focused on bolstering border security and deportation efforts, with the previous administration making immigration enforcement a key policy priority. Yet, despite these efforts, illegal immigration continues to rise, as evidenced by the significant increases in border apprehensions in 2023.
The economic and social strains of illegal aliens have, in many cases, amplified xenophobia across the United States. Xenophobia refers to the fear or hatred of people from other countries, often manifesting as hostility or discrimination toward immigrants. As the burden on public services, healthcare, and law enforcement increases, so too does resentment among some segments of the population. This resentment can fuel anti-immigrant sentiment and lead to an increase in hate crimes and discriminatory behaviors against immigrant communities, both legal and illegal.
Recent data highlights this troubling trend. According to a 2022 FBI report, hate crimes against immigrants have risen by 30% over the past five years, with a notable spike in racially motivated attacks on Latino and Asian communities. The Pew Research Center conducted a survey in 2023 that found 57% of Americans believe immigrants, particularly those who are undocumented, are a strain on the economy, with 41% saying that immigrants increase the risk of crime. These perceptions, though often not supported by data, fuel xenophobic rhetoric and contribute to a growing divide in public opinion on immigration.
Cities with large immigrant populations, such as Los Angeles and New York, have reported increased tensions, as demonstrated by the rise in hate crimes targeting immigrant communities. The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) found that hate crimes against Latinos rose by 19% in 2023 alone, underscoring the connection between immigration debates and xenophobic actions.
These growing levels of xenophobia pose a significant challenge, as they not only harm immigrant communities but also complicate efforts to create inclusive, fair immigration policies. Addressing the societal impacts of illegal immigration will require not only economic and policy reforms but also a concerted effort to counter xenophobic attitudes and misinformation.
Immigration Bill: Recent Policy Debates
In 2023, a significant immigration bill known as the US Citizenship Act was introduced in Congress but failed to pass due to partisan divisions. This legislation sought to provide an eight-year pathway to citizenship for approximately 11 million undocumented immigrants currently living in the US, including Dreamers, Temporary Protected Status (TPS) holders, and essential workers. The bill also aimed to strengthen border security through modern technology while addressing root causes of migration by investing in Central American economies.
Had this bill passed, it would have profoundly impacted both the U.S. economy and the undocumented immigrant population. According to the Center for American Progress, the pathway to citizenship would have increased U.S. GDP by $1.7 trillion over the next decade and created 438,800 new jobs. Additionally, undocumented immigrants, once legalized, would have contributed an estimated $27 billion in federal and state taxes annually. However, opponents argued that the bill lacked sufficient provisions for border enforcement and would incentivize further illegal immigration. The bill’s failure means the current immigration system remains in limbo, continuing the strain on public services and the legal uncertainties faced by millions of undocumented immigrants.
The Future of "Illegal "Immigration
The challenges posed by "illegal" immigration will likely persist as global economic inequality, political instability, and climate change continue to drive people across borders. Addressing these issues will require a balanced approach, with potential solutions ranging from stricter border enforcement to comprehensive immigration reform that addresses the root causes of migration.
While immigration enriches American society, the economic and logistical burdens of illegal immigration must be addressed in a fair and sustainable way to ensure that public services, infrastructure, and resources are not unduly strained.
"Illegal" immigration is a multifaceted issue that places significant burdens on the US, its states, and its cities. As the population of undocumented immigrants grows, so too does the need for comprehensive solutions that balance economic realities with humanitarian concerns.
How do we measure the impact of immigration reform
1. Economic Impact (GDP Growth, Job Creation, Tax Revenue and Wage Growth)
2. Social Impact (Education and Healthcare Costs, Crime Rates & Public Safety and Cultural Integration)
3. Demographic Changes (Population Growth and Urbanization)
4. Policy Impact (Border Security and Immigration Enforcement and Legal Pathways and Naturalization Rates)
5. Public Opinion and Political Impact (Public Sentiment and Electoral Outcomes)
References:
Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), 2023 report on the cost of illegal immigration.
2. Pew Research Center, immigration trends and statistics, 2022.
3. Department of Homeland Security, border enforcement data, 2023.
U.S. Census Bureau, population estimates for undocumented immigrants.
FBI, 2022 Hate Crime Statistics Report.
Pew Research Center, American attitudes toward immigrants, 2023.
Anti-Defamation League (ADL), 2023 report on hate crimes against immigrants.
Center for American Progress, 2023 report on the economic impact of immigration reform.
U.S. Congress, U.S. Citizenship Act of 2023.
Migration Policy Institute, 2023 analysis of immigration legislation.